Why You Can't Skip to Expert-Level AI Collaboration True expertise has a nested architecture where each layer builds
Expertise builds in nested layers, but AI can generate outputs without foundational structure. Learn how "Symbolic Plasticity" helps professionals use AI to reveal connections across expertise layers while preserving deep knowledge integrity.
A Co-Created Manifesto for a Future with AI We are delighted to announce that we will be partnering with IDEO
Expertise builds in nested layers, but AI can generate outputs without foundational structure. Learn how "Symbolic Plasticity" helps professionals use AI to reveal connections across expertise layers while preserving deep knowledge integrity.
This post is part of our series on expertise and AI. If you're concerned about preserving and enhancing the value of your expertise as AI advances, consider joining our short course—starting August 6th—to learn the psychological strategies needed to make your expertise even more valuable with AI.
Join our AI Course for Leaders to learn how to Become More Essential with Artificial Intelligence. While most AI courses focus on tools, we focus on minds—helping you build the human capabilities that make you more essential in a machine-shaped world.
Our research with 1000+ professionals reveals that a key difference between those who become more valuable with AI versus those who become replaceable isn't technical skill, it's their psychological strategy.
Join us for an immersive, personal learning experience—starts August 6th!
Expertise is structured like a set of nested layers—each skill or concept built on the foundation of others. You can’t fully grasp the outermost layers without understanding what’s inside. This nested architecture is what gives expertise its depth, stability, and adaptability over time.
AI can generate sophisticated outputs that appear expert-level—strategies, analysis, polished writing—but without the underlying layers of understanding, it’s hard to evaluate, adapt, or build on what it produces. In our Chronicle research, we’ve seen this moment of realization again and again: professionals mid-collaboration with AI, suddenly aware that something foundational is missing.
The professionals who thrive in these situations use AI to explore and reinforce the structure of their own expertise. They’ve developed what we call Symbolic Plasticity—the ability to reframe meaning, see how different layers connect, and consciously navigate between them. Rather than skipping steps or flattening complexity, they use AI to move more fluidly across the layers, strengthening both judgment and creative insight.
Recent research on skill dependencies and job mobility confirms this pattern: the most resilient and rewarded forms of expertise are those aligned with a nested structure. Symbolic Plasticity helps professionals stay rooted in that structure, even as the surface of their work changes. Expert collaboration with AI is more about staying attuned to how meaning and value evolve, and how to evolve with them, than it is about learning how to prompt or building an agent.
Financial analysts start by learning isolated metrics—P/E ratios, debt-to-equity, revenue growth rates. With experience, these elements cluster into recognizable patterns: "value trap," "growth at reasonable price," "turnaround story." Eventually, experienced analysts develop intuitive pattern recognition—they scan an earnings report and sense something's off in the narrative before they've checked the footnotes.
Each layer contains and builds on all the previous ones. You can't crack open the biggest doll and expect to understand how everything fits together.
This nested architecture explains why AI-generated shortcuts often create expertise that looks sophisticated from the outside but lacks structural integrity. A junior analyst using AI to generate investment recommendations might produce impressive reports without understanding the foundational reasoning that makes them work. When facing novel market conditions, the absence of deep structure becomes obvious.
In our Chronicle study, we tracked how professionals first encounter AI's ability to reveal connections they hadn't seen. This "Recognition" phase is where Symbolic Plasticity becomes crucial.
Take a financial analyst who's spent years building nested expertise: market indicators → sector patterns → economic cycles → systemic risks. When they first use AI to analyze market data, they might discover the AI identifies patterns that span multiple layers of their expertise simultaneously.
The question becomes, can they reframe their understanding to accommodate these new connections, or do they stay in their existing categorical thinking?
High Symbolic Plasticity professionals describe this moment as revelatory—recognizing that concepts they'd kept in separate categories actually operate as part of larger systems. They're reorganizing their expertise rather than replacing it and begin to tackle even more complex problems.
We observe SP developing through AI experience. Seasoned professionals learn to recognize when AI shows them something genuinely new about their domain—patterns spanning areas they'd kept separate, or connections they'd never considered. This recognition builds their comfort with reframing. Less experienced professionals often apply AI insights correctly but miss the larger story about how their own thinking could evolve, lacking the meta-awareness to see what's really happening. This ultimately becomes a limiting factor on their growth.
As professionals move into regular AI collaboration, those with high Symbolic Plasticity develop what we observe as "dynamic relationships" with their nested expertise. They learn to consciously move between different layers depending on what AI reveals.
Our Chronicle participants describe learning to ask themselves: "Is AI helping me see connections within this layer of my expertise, or is it revealing relationships between layers I hadn't considered?"
A marketing strategist might use AI to explore consumer behavior patterns (one layer), then realize the AI is actually revealing connections between consumer psychology and economic indicators (spanning multiple layers). High SP allows them to reframe their expertise to incorporate these cross-layer insights.
The expertise layers remain intact, but AI helps reveal how they connect and influence each other in ways that weren't previously visible.
The nested structure of expertise creates what we call "expertise hierarchies"—each layer provides context and meaning for the others. AI can process information across all these layers simultaneously, but it doesn't build them in a context-dependent way—its patterns tend to be more averaged across domains rather than shaped by specific professional experience.
When you have high Symbolic Plasticity, you can:
Chronicle participants with high SP described feeling like AI helped them "see their own knowledge from new angles" rather than replacing their knowledge with something external.
Professionals with high Symbolic Plasticity develop expertise that maintains its nested structure while incorporating new organizational principles that AI reveals.
The key is developing the psychological flexibility to let AI reorganize your understanding while maintaining the deep structure that makes expertise valuable. Your expertise layers evolve to work together in more sophisticated ways.
Ready to develop the Symbolic Plasticity that makes expert-AI collaboration actually work? Learn the psychological strategies that help you reframe your expertise without losing its foundational strength. Join our short course—starting August 6th—to learn the psychological strategies needed to make your expertise even more valuable with AI.
